I tend to keep my c.v. in circulation, even when gainfully employed, because you never know what will happen and when. The problem is that I loathe applying for jobs. So much work, so little in return. For instance, today I spent three and a half hours applying for two job. Only two. Online. I have no idea why it should take this long, especially since I had all of the information with which to fill out the online forms set out in front of me. After all of this, I may never hear from either institution again in my life. I will never know if they are missing one crucial piece of information, or if one document attached did not go through. I will never know if this is the reason that I never heard from them again.Applying for jobs in the educational field can sometimes feel like stepping through the Looking Glass. For instance, one of the applications today asked about "learning-centeredness." The question went something to the effect of "demonstrate your understanding of learning-centeredness and the role of full-time faculty in a learning-centered college." I seriously wanted to answer, "What the fuck?"
Seriously, what the hell is "learning-centeredness"? It is a college, for chrissakes: a place where people go to learn. Therefore, the function of the college is centered on learning. A teacher, as the employee of the college who instills the learning, is, by nature, inherently centered on students learning. I have to write an essay on the function of a teacher, at a school, where people go to learn? How dumb have your previous applicants been? On top of that, would a student know how to answer the questions, "Was your instructor learning-centered?" or "Was your college learning-centered?"
The question felt like a trick question, as if there is no right answer, they just want to see what the applicants come up with. Perhaps there is some code. If you know the right jargon or the right phrases, then you have passed the initiation rites. Maybe the question is on the application as a CYA measure for the institution, as some sort of jargon-filled accreditation requirement.
Maybe the question is the product of action taken to statistically prove that students don't feel the way that I felt when I said that, at my university, the students and faculty seemed to get in the way of the business of the institution. Sometimes I wonder if the people immediately on the other end of these types of questions find them ponderous and useless as a real tool of evaluation.
Maybe the question is the product of action taken to statistically prove that students don't feel the way that I felt when I said that, at my university, the students and faculty seemed to get in the way of the business of the institution. Sometimes I wonder if the people immediately on the other end of these types of questions find them ponderous and useless as a real tool of evaluation.Sometimes, I feel like a near-sighted pawn in a country of nekkid emperors.

12 comments:
I laughed out loud when I read this, thanks!
I'm soon to be applying for jobs myself, and not at all looking forward to it. I'm sick and tired to death of the career I"ve had for the past 11 years, but I don't really know what else my skills are useful for, so I dunno. but at least, hopefully, this fall I won't have to work at all because I'll be too busy with school. so whatever job I end up with for the summer is only for the summer! Thank GOD!
best of luck with your apps.
Thank you! Good luck, as well!
To be honest I'm not sure what exactly the problem is in asking applicants to discuss their role as teacher. While I've had some excellent teachers through two M.A. programs I've come across just as many who have no business being in front of the classroom. I often wonder whether universities do enough in preparing their Phd candidates to teach.
Does completing a PhD in a very narrow area and some time as a teaching assistant really prepare one for a career as a teacher? Just some thoughts as I read your post. Good luck with the job search.
Kevin at Civil War Memory: www.civilwarmemory.typepad.com
Well, in this particular instance, I found the question to be a bit nonsensical and not really actually asking anything about teaching.
You do raise an excellent point about PhD programs in no way preparing their students to become teachers. At best, PhD students learn to become teachers by watching their own professors who themselves probably have no clue as to how to educate anyone. I actually am working on a post that deals with that subject because this failure to educate neophyte professors in how to actually do their jobs does a huge disservice to the PhD student and to the students that they will subsequently teach.
Thank you for stopping by and for commenting.
You may want to check out my latest post on a recent report released by a conference of history professors and high school teachers on how history departments can better prepare their students to teach, etc. The links are available from my post at Civil War Memory or just go to the AHA blog.
Kevin, I commented over at your site on that post, which was fabulous.
hey all,
being on the receiving end of many a lecture and presentation that really kinda sucked, I gotta say, I think everyone who teaches at university should have some training in adult education. It's not enough to simply get up at the front of a room and talk about stuff. There is a particular kind of dynamic that needs to occur for adults to learn, and not everyone learns in the same way.
I took a three-day workshop in adult education a couple of years ago, and it was so enlightening and helpful. I think it's a pretty standard sort of program, called Train the Trainer, and I often find myself wishing that more people knew about the techniques it taught. I've used some of those techniques in every academic presentation I've ever given, and always scored really well with both profs and fellow students.
just a thought - perhaps PhD program should include a workshop like the one I took.
Thinking Girl, thank you for your comment. That right, right there, from a student, is what we are talking about! Sometimes, I seriously think that graduate programs forget that they are training teachers. They know that they are training specialists who will contribute to their field of study, and do what they can to teach research methods and the ways to think about the subject; but the teaching skills seem to get left out, to the detriment of all involved.
To add, at the very least, such a seminar as you mention, should be a part of graduate programs.
yeah! let's start a movement for the education of academic educators!
what about this: does the college/university you study at have an education program, or perhaps is it affiliated with a college (mine is affiliated with a skills-based college, which is where I took the workshop in question)? Perhaps approaching the department and specifically asking for such a course, if they have some funding available, would get some results. They'd be more likely to accept if they didn't really have to pay but could allow you to audit the class for free or something. Most of the folks in the class I took had their employers paying for them to take it. Or of course, you could take the class on your own and then just show them how much more effective your teaching is compared to those who haven't taken it.
just some brainstorming, I don't have any idea how these things work, but I perhaps even just bringing it up at a grad dept meeting might generate some interest. I know that almost all of the grad students I've had in classes have basically been terrified the first time they had to present a lecture to the class, so I bet learning some techniques to get everyone at ease and do an effective presentation would really helpo confidence levels.
Thinking Girl, that is actually a great set of ideas. You have inspired me to write a new post(referencing you of course!), if you don't mind.
oh, by all means! it's my pleasure to send my loosey-goosey ideas out into the world for others to follow through on! :)
If you like, I could offer up some of what I learned doing the workshop. just email me if you'd like to know a bit more about what I learned. I hesitate to post it publicly, I believe I had to sign a waiver saying I wouldn't attempt to teach the workshop myself... I do still have all my course materials, though.
Post a Comment